Monday, November 06, 2006

Common Sense isn't common

Recently I've been hearing the words "common sense" as a means of excusing poor parenting advice. "The Strong-Willed Child is a great book, as long as you use common sense. Baby-wise is not harmful, if you use common sense." And I've been accused of not using common sense because I followed the "strong-willed child" advice when obviously my child was not strong-willed, but autistic.
I feel a need to defend not only myself, but those I know who have recovered from practicing bad parenting advice on their children. Not because I don't think that what was done to these children was wrong. Not because I don't think common sense is useful. Not because I want to make excuses for parenting mistakes. But because I think that there is more to the story than just not using common sense.
I was raised in an authoritarian household in which I was taught not to question authority. Those with authority always knew what was right, and I needed to just keep my mouth shut and follow them. I was not given the tools needed to make right decisions on my own. The decisions I made were based on outward stimuli - will I get into trouble if I do this? Will I make someone upset? - not on whether I felt in my heart it was right or wrong.
There are currently many persuasive writers in parenting circles. Ezzo, Pearl, Tripp, Dobson. They base their parenting advice on fear, and outward stimuli. They don't tell you to use common sense, they don't urge you to research your decisions yourself and check it against what you feel the holy spirit is telling you. They tell you that they are the authority, and we are not to question authority.
These authors don't usually take into account all the variety of family situations that will be reading their material. One way tends to be the right way for all.

Solomon Asch did a study in the 1950's that is very revealing. When placed in a group of peers, he discovered that "the tendency to conformity in our society is so strong that reasonably intelligent and well-meaning young people are willing to call white black." Even though you may firmly believe your answer is right, when those who you are around are saying that another answer is right, you begin to say that their answer is right, as well. First, because you want to be liked by the group, and second because you begin to believe the group is better informed than you. Some people in the experiment even began to see the wrong answers as truly correct.

Another study worthy of note is the Milgram Experiment. This experiment showed that people tend to obey authority at all cost, even when they feel that what the authority tells them to do is wrong. Even when they were warned that what they were doing could cause great harm to another person, 65% of the subjects punished the other person to the maximum, harmful amount when the authority told them to.

So, how does one apply common sense if they are not taught to use it?

Unfortunately, my dear children had to be my guinea pigs as I learned to think on my own, research my decisions, come to my own conclusions, and explore common sense as it conflicted with authority figures.

As the mother of a child on the autism spectrum, I struggle with trying to teach my own children to use common sense. Seeing the world in black and white can become very harmful to a child if they believe that all adults do the right thing. I strive to teach them to listen to their instincts, to be okay with questioning authority, and to have the tools to make wise decisions on their own.

I see so many parents falling prey to parenting "experts" who abuse their authority. Perhaps these parents were raised the same way, and would not even consider questioning the validity of the advice they are following. It's gotten to the point where the wrong answer has become right because all those around them say it's right.

Lord, help me to see the truth in the world, and to pass this truth onto my children.

No comments: